Page 2 of 3 FirstFirst 123 LastLast
Results 11 to 20 of 30

Thread: Broadhead test

  1. #11
    Senior Member Ehunter's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2010
    Location
    Southeast Kansas
    Posts
    1,768
    Post Thanks / Like

    Default Testing is complete

    I did change a few things up, but believe it's still a valid test. All shot were from 20 yards. All heads are 100 gr. except where noted.
    Bow: 65# Alien X
    Arrow: Easton 2216 Lite @ 399.4 gr.
    Target: Cow ribs (all within .15 thickness) in front of a Block target
    Arrow speed calculated at 249 fps
    KE calculated at 69 ft/lbs

    Penetration Depth:
    1. Shuttle T Locks
    2. Magnus Buzzcut
    3. Wasp Bullet
    4. Thunderhead (85 gr.) (lost one blade)
    5. ABC Sonic Pro (85 gr.)
    6. Rage 2 Blade
    7. Swhacker
    8. Slick Trick Magnum (no penetration past blades)

    Durability:

    1. Magnus Buzzcut ( dulled blades, no visible damage)
    2. Shuttle T Lock (dulled blades, slight nick in blade,)
    3. Wasp Boss Bullet (dulled blades, edge bent over on one blade)
    4. Thunderhead (lost one blade, others dulled)
    5. ABC Sonic Pro (dulled blades, edges bent, tip folded over"
    6. Rage 2 Blade (dulled blades, badly bent blades"
    7. Slick Trick Magnum (dulled blades, edges bent over, blades bent in towards each other losing the "X" pattern)
    8. Swhacker (totally demolished, ferrule badly bent, blades bent, only one blade deployed due to damage)

    Overall Performance:
    1. Shuttle T Locks
    2. Magnus Buzzcut (very close to #1)
    3. Wasp Boss Bullet
    4. Thunderhead
    5. ABC Sonic Pro
    6. Rage 2 Blade
    7. Swhacker
    8. Slick Trick Magnum

    The top 3 heads are all basically a toss up on which performed best. Slightly better penetration was the deciding factor in the overall. Had the Thunderhead not lost a blade, it would have been in the same running. The big suprises to me were failure of the Slick Trick Magnums (I have taken several deer with them and like them), the lack of damage to even the bleeder blades on the Magnus Buzzcut, and the total failure of the Swhacker.
    Pics are in the next post. Feel free to ask me anything about the test.
    Last edited by Ehunter; 06-24-2012 at 05:51 PM.
    2008 Moab 70# The deer killing bow
    2008/12 Firecat 60#--- 2010 Warthog 70#
    2009 Warthog 70#---2009-10-12? Warthog Frankenbow with Nitrous B
    2010 Strother SR-71 65# & 2012 Strother Rush 65#
    2012 Strother SX Rush 60# & 2011 Strother Infinity 70#
    BSD strings and cables

    Yeah, I know I'm grumpy and opinionated.

  2. #12
    Senior Member Ehunter's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2010
    Location
    Southeast Kansas
    Posts
    1,768
    Post Thanks / Like
    2008 Moab 70# The deer killing bow
    2008/12 Firecat 60#--- 2010 Warthog 70#
    2009 Warthog 70#---2009-10-12? Warthog Frankenbow with Nitrous B
    2010 Strother SR-71 65# & 2012 Strother Rush 65#
    2012 Strother SX Rush 60# & 2011 Strother Infinity 70#
    BSD strings and cables

    Yeah, I know I'm grumpy and opinionated.

  3. #13
    Senior Member Ehunter's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2010
    Location
    Southeast Kansas
    Posts
    1,768
    Post Thanks / Like

    Default

    Rage 2 Blade 100 gr..JPGSlick Trick Magnum 100gr..JPGSwhacker 100 gr..JPGSwhacker 100 gr. 2.JPG


    As you can clearly see, the Swhacker was destroyed. The Slick Trick Magnum, Rage, And ABC Sonic Pro were all pretty badly damaged. While the Thunderhead lost one blade, the others were still relatively sharp, and locked in place. The Wasp, Magnus, and T Lock all sustained minor damage, and still retained a decent or better edge on the blades. If not for the glancing blow on the T Lock, it's blades could have been resharpened, and the head reused. The Magnus simply needed resharpened. It was the most durable, but had less penetration than the Shuttle T Lock. The Wasp and Thunderhead needed one blade replaced, and the others sharpened. All other heads needed all the blades replaced, or the head thrown away. Hope this helps someone in deciding what heads to use. If nothing else, it was kinda fun (but expensive) to do. lol
    2008 Moab 70# The deer killing bow
    2008/12 Firecat 60#--- 2010 Warthog 70#
    2009 Warthog 70#---2009-10-12? Warthog Frankenbow with Nitrous B
    2010 Strother SR-71 65# & 2012 Strother Rush 65#
    2012 Strother SX Rush 60# & 2011 Strother Infinity 70#
    BSD strings and cables

    Yeah, I know I'm grumpy and opinionated.

  4. #14
    Senior Member Skbengal's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2009
    Location
    Sask,Ca
    Posts
    141
    Post Thanks / Like

    Default

    Ehunter, wow, those are some suprising results! Especially the mechanicals. So can we assume you've made your choice of broadhead for your upcoming moose hunt?

  5. #15
    Senior Member Ehunter's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2010
    Location
    Southeast Kansas
    Posts
    1,768
    Post Thanks / Like

    Default

    Sk, it'll be a toss up between the Shuttle T Locks and the Magnus for sure. Just depends on which one flies best with the bow I decide to take. Been a big fan of the T Locks since I started shooting them a few years ago. Watched on old g/f make a quartering to shot on a buck at 23 yards. Complete pass through with a 40 pound draw weight. Not a huge buck, but a good 160 pound'er. That was impressive enough for me. lol As far as the Magnus, I was very impressed that the tip didn't try to curl or deform at all on impact. I like the way they have it shaped into more of a chisel than a straight edge. That has to add alot of strength. I think either head will be as effective on anything a person would hunt.
    2008 Moab 70# The deer killing bow
    2008/12 Firecat 60#--- 2010 Warthog 70#
    2009 Warthog 70#---2009-10-12? Warthog Frankenbow with Nitrous B
    2010 Strother SR-71 65# & 2012 Strother Rush 65#
    2012 Strother SX Rush 60# & 2011 Strother Infinity 70#
    BSD strings and cables

    Yeah, I know I'm grumpy and opinionated.

  6. #16
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    May 2009
    Location
    Colorado
    Posts
    1,697
    Post Thanks / Like

    Default

    Your test dont suprise me but then - I've been shooting Magnus since about '92.
    I am curious tho - did the Buzzcut stop when the bleeder blades were stuck in the bone?

  7. #17
    Senior Member Ehunter's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2010
    Location
    Southeast Kansas
    Posts
    1,768
    Post Thanks / Like

    Default

    The buzzcut literally snapped the rib in half, and just kept going. It had a good 12-13 inches of penetration into the Block target after destroying the rib. Honestly, the head is still as sharp as some I've seen in people's quivers. Sharper than some of the other heads came from the factory.
    2008 Moab 70# The deer killing bow
    2008/12 Firecat 60#--- 2010 Warthog 70#
    2009 Warthog 70#---2009-10-12? Warthog Frankenbow with Nitrous B
    2010 Strother SR-71 65# & 2012 Strother Rush 65#
    2012 Strother SX Rush 60# & 2011 Strother Infinity 70#
    BSD strings and cables

    Yeah, I know I'm grumpy and opinionated.

  8. #18
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    May 2009
    Location
    Colorado
    Posts
    1,697
    Post Thanks / Like

    Default

    Thanks.
    I usually use the 100gn 2-blades for deer and elk and the 4-blades for turkey and antelope.
    May try the 4-blade for deer this year.
    They are tough tho. I've shot them into a bunch of different things and the only one I've really broken was shot at a good shovel from about
    5yds...

    Buzzcut.jpg

  9. #19
    Senior Member Ehunter's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2010
    Location
    Southeast Kansas
    Posts
    1,768
    Post Thanks / Like

    Default

    100_0738.JPG100_0741.JPG100_0739.JPG100_0740.JPG
    To make Spiker smile, I did another quick test this afternoon. It's 103 outside, so it was a quick test. lol Shot the top 2 heads through matching (same cow) shoulder bones roughly 1/2 inch thick. The Shuttle T lock had 13 inches of penetration, one small flat spot on one blade, blades were slightly dulled, and the tip was slightly out of shape, but repairable. The Magnus had no damage to the main blades, other than a slight dulling, but the bleeder blades had the cutting edges rolled over and needed replaced. It had 12 1/4 inches of penetration. Penetration was into a Block target behind the shoulder bones for both shots. Both heads are 1 1/8th inch cut. These two heads have impressed the hell out of me.
    2008 Moab 70# The deer killing bow
    2008/12 Firecat 60#--- 2010 Warthog 70#
    2009 Warthog 70#---2009-10-12? Warthog Frankenbow with Nitrous B
    2010 Strother SR-71 65# & 2012 Strother Rush 65#
    2012 Strother SX Rush 60# & 2011 Strother Infinity 70#
    BSD strings and cables

    Yeah, I know I'm grumpy and opinionated.

  10. #20
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    May 2009
    Location
    Colorado
    Posts
    1,697
    Post Thanks / Like

    Default

    Thats why I shoot the 2-blades. The bleeder blades slow 'em down when they hit something substantial.
    I've shot them a bunch thru 55 gallon steel barrels and the fletching is what stops the arrow.
    Now on a live critter - that probably isn't so. They give a bit more than steel...
    A buzzcut on a bareshaft blows thru a steel drum .

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •